Euro 2024: 'Deepfake' Gareth Southgate social media videos anger FA – BBC
The videos were made to look like Gareth Southgate news conferences
At a major tournament England head coach Gareth Southgate's words are analysed, deconstructed and debated.
But Euro 2024 has brought a new dimension – AI-generated fake interviews with the England boss that are being viewed by millions on social media.
These fake clips purporting to show Southgate making crude remarks about his players have been called "offensive" by the Football Association.
The videos have been circulating on TikTok and Instagram.
They include derogatory comments about England's Euro 2024 players as well as those who were not selected.
Comments on the social sites suggest the material, about players such as Phil Foden, Jordan Henderson, Jack Grealish and Marcus Rashford, had been believed by some viewers.
The videos are all made to look like Southgate is giving press conferences, but use an AI voice generator to overlay fake words and artificially move his mouth.
In one of them the artificial voice apologises "to the nation" for the manager's performance and criticises players.
In another, the fake Southgate says: "I think we really missed Jordan Henderson's presence out there tonight."
BBC Sport spoke to several England fans in Germany who had seen the material on social media.
The majority said they found the content funny.
"It's the classic stereotypical British humour. It helps build a bit of morale to keep people motivated and happy, so I think it's harmless fun," one supporter told BBC Sport.
"Apparently, Gareth doesn’t read anything or watch any social media anyway."
Another described some of the videos as "quite funny" but pointed out it was not just the England manager who has been targeted.
"I've seen a lot of players and, during the season, [Jurgen] Klopp, Pep [Guardiola] and [Mikel] Arteta getting it too."
However, the FA said in a statement: "As we do with all harmful content we will take steps to have these offensive videos removed.
"Gareth and everyone in camp are focused on Sunday’s game."
England won Group C of Euro 2024 and face Slovakia in the last 16 – but there has been criticism of the way England have played as well as of Southgate personally.
Earlier this year London Mayor Sadiq Khan said deepfake audio of him supposedly making inflammatory remarks before Armistice Day almost caused "serious disorder".
And former Justice Secretary Sir Robert Buckland said AI videos in politics represent a "clear and present danger" to UK democracy.
While AI-generated content is allowed on TikTok and Instagram, there are rules on what content is considered harmful.
Shortly after the BBC approached TikTok about a number of videos on one account, the material disappeared.
It is understood it was taken down because it repeated violations of the platform's AIGC policies.
Meta, which owns Instagram, was also reviewing the material.
Experts warned that those in positions of power were not the only ones vulnerable to this kind of manipulation.
Professor Hany Farid, a digital forensics expert at the University of California, said: "It's not just people who have a big digital footprint whose identity can be co-opted.
"I can take as little as 30 seconds of someone’s voice, as short as a single image of somebody, and create deepfakes of them."
He added that there was a delicate balance to strike with regulation when it comes to satire.
"It's one thing to have an article that is satirical, making fun of a politician or an athlete," he said.
"It is very different to have a video of that person in their voice and in their likeness that can be quite offensive, and I think the courts, and we as a society, are going to have to think about where we draw that line."
'Who else? Iconic Bellingham goal will go down in England history'
Williams scores stunner as Spain beat Georgia to set up Germany quarter- final
'A little bit desperate' – Norris fumes at Verstappen move
Where parties stand on the key issues
If you’re unclear, this guide on the BBC News website and app gives you a summary
Every dreamer deserves a shot…
The heart-warming true story of Maurice Flitcroft, the world's most subpar golfer
How Cancún became a world-beating destination
From a secret Mexican island to a hotspot for tourists, pollution and crime
A strange sighting starts many unexplained events
Sian Eleri sets out to uncover if a Welsh village was really visited by UFOs over 30 years ago
'Bellingham goal will go down in England history'
Five Wimbledon storylines to look out for
Bellingham rescues England with injury-time overhead kick. Video
'A little bit desperate' – Norris fumes at Verstappen move
'Decisive 16 seconds' from 'ridiculous' VAR as German 'belief' grows
Hero to villain in 75 seconds – Andersen's denied goal then concedes penalty. Video
'No Mbappe or Ronaldo', Fiat Panda jibes – but Spalletti to stay
'Don't disrespect me' – Joshua and Dubois interview gets heated. Video
'Truly historic' – Bensel makes back-to-back holes-in-one
It was supposed to be a recovery bike ride – Gordon. Video
Panenka – the penalty that killed a career and started a feud
England could go further than fans and critics expect – Hitzlsperger column
'A World Cup final where history beckons either way'
Unofficial transfer deadline looms for clubs to comply with PSR
Paris 2024 chief 'confident' River Seine will be used
Kane in crisis, toxic pressure – what Europe thinks of England
Dog bite causes Korda to miss tournament in England
Cavendish show backdrop to huge battle for Tour de France yellow
India 'humble' England to reach T20 World Cup final. Video
Billionaire ex-PM offers £8.4m gift to Georgia squad
© 2024 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
